Law and the Limits of Reason

Author: Adrian Vermeule
Publisher: Oxford University Press USA
ISBN: 9780195383768
Published In: January 2009
Format: Hardback , 224 pages
Jurisdiction: U.S. ? Disclaimer:
Countri(es) stated herein are used as reference only

Out of stock

Description
Contents
Author

Details

Discusses how the legal and political system is limited by the processing capacity of the brain, by errors arising from cognitive heuristics, by the intrinsic costs of information, and sometimes by emotions.
Provides a signal contribution to one of the hottest topics in contemporary democratic theory, "epistemic democracy."
Questions what's behind the curtain of "settled practices" or "legal rules" and asks to what extent are these in fact a constellation of less-than-rational judgments?

Human reason is limited. Given the scarcity of reason, how should the power to make constitutional law be allocated among legislatures, courts and the executive, and how should legal institutions be designed? In Law and the Limits of Reason, Adrian Vermeule denies the widespread view, stemming from Burke and Hayek, that the limits of reason counsel in favor of judges making "living" constitutional law in the style of the common law. Instead, he proposes and defends a "codified constitution" - a regime in which legislatures have the primary authority to develop constitutional law over time, through statutes and constitutional amendments.

Vermeule contends that precisely because of the limits of human reason, large modern legislatures, with their numerous and highly diverse memberships and their complex internal structures for processing information, are the most epistemically effective lawmaking institutions.

Introduction: The Limits of Reason in Legal Theory
Chapter 1: Many-Minds Arguments
Chapter 2: The Constitutional Common Law: Information Aggregation
Chapter 3: The Constitutional Common Law: Evolution
Chapter 4: Justices and Company
Chapter 5: Unintended Consequences and Constitutional Amendments
Conclusion: From the Common-Law Constitution to the Codified Constitution
Acknowledgements
Index

Adrian Vermeule is the John H. Watson Professor of Law at Harvard Law School. Before joining the Harvard faculty, he previously taught at the University of Chicago Law School for seven years, where he was twice awarded with the Graduating Students' Award for Teaching Excellence. He also served as a clerk to Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonin Scalia and Judge David Sentelle of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.