New Directions in Ombud Research: Empirical and Critical Perspectives

Author: Julia Dahlvik; Axel Pohn-Weidinger
Publisher: Hart Publishing
ISBN: 9781509992775
Published In: December 2026
Format: Hardback
Jurisdiction: U.K. ? Disclaimer:
Countri(es) stated herein are used as reference only

HKD 1,235.00

Download Order Form

Add to Wishlist
| Add to Compare

Description
Contents

Details

This book brings together theoretical and empirical research, as well as interdisciplinary and comparative studies to direct the contemporary debates within the field of ombuds scholarship.

Most countries have public ombuds institutions that function as mechanisms for dispute resolution alternative to the courts for citizens who seek redress for complaints against public bodies. While research on these oversight bodies has long focused on legal aspects, since the last decade historical, political and social aspects are increasingly studied. This book makes a contribution in this multi-disciplinary field by filling two key gaps in the literature: the first part showcases critical theoretical approaches, the second part covers recent empirical research.

Taken together, the approach laid out in this volume promotes a sociological understanding of ombuds institutions as embedded in specific social contexts, which are formed by societal forces while also contributing to the shaping of modern societies. Critical examination of how and under which conditions ombuds operate helps identify blind spots in both the literature and practice. On the basis of case studies from different world regions, including Australia, Colombia, France, Germany, Ireland, Netherlands, Spain, Turkey, the UK and the USA, investigated from various disciplinary perspectives, the combined contributions allow us to develop the field of ombuds research further. Its contents and accessible style make the book relevant for anyone interested in ombuds and oversight institutions: academics, researchers, students, and practitioners alike.

Introduction, Julia Dahlvik (University of Applied Sciences FH Campus Wien, Austria), Axel Pohn-Weidinger (Universite de Strasbourg, France)

Part 1: Empirical Perspectives

1. The Office of the Ombudsman and Prisoner Complaints: Ireland, a Case Study, Sophie Van der Valk (University College Dublin, Ireland)

2. Pathways to Justice Through the Ombuds and Tribunal in the UK: Housing and Special Educational Needs, Naomi Creutzfeld (Kent Law School, UK)

3. Independence and Accountability of Ombuds Institutions in Europe, Luka Glusac (University of Belgrade, Serbia)

4. The Organization-Agent Narrative: Street-Level Bureaucracy & Campus Sexual Misconduct, Brian Pappas (University of North Dakota, USA)

5. The Digital Transformation of Public Services: A Global Comparison of Problems and Challenges from the Ombuds' Perspective, Julia Dahlvik (University of Applied Sciences FH Campus Wien, Austria)

6. The Achilles' Heel of the French Human Rights Ombudsmen: Financial Dependence of an Independent Body, Julien Mouchette (University of Reims, France)

7. How Can the Ombudsman Strengthen the Rule of Law? A Case Study from the Netherlands, Marc Hertogh (Utrecht University, the Netherlands)

8. The Ombud and the Control of Bureaucratic Decision-Making: The Case of the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman and Local Authority Education Decision-Makers in England, Chris Gill (University of Glasgow, UK)

9. Ombud in Protecting the Right to Social Security: The Case of Turkiye, Hicran Atatanir (Social Security Institution of Turkiye)

Part 2: Critical Perspectives

10. Ombuds Claiming and Social Inequalities: An Exploration of Legal Transformation Through the Example of the Colombian Personeria, Markus Ciesielski (Hildesheim University, Germany)

11. Ombudsman and Hybridity: Global Model and Shape-Shifting Institution, Tero Erkkila and Juho Moelsa (University of Helsinki, Finland)

12. What Can be Learned from Ombudsman Mistakes?, Matthew Groves (Deakin University, Australia), Anita Stuhmke (University of Technology, Sydney)

13. Ombuds and Mediation: Towards People-Centered Justice and Democratic Practice, Nick O'Brien (The Mental Health Tribunal, UK)

14. Human Rights Ombudsmen as Mediators: A Comparison between France and Spain, Rhita Bousta (Universite Paris I Pantheon-Sorbonne, France)

15. UK Ombudsmen: Their Role in Improving Administration and Public Services, Robert Thomas (University of Manchester, UK)

16. Waves, Cultures or Fields? Towards a Sociological Theory of the Emergence of Public Ombuds Institutions, Axel Pohn-Weidinger (University of Strasbourg, France)