Tax Avoidance and the Law: Understanding the UK General Anti-Abuse Rule

Taxation › Taxation

Tax Avoidance and the Law: Understanding the UK General Anti-Abuse Rule

By Selina Keesoony
Routledge January 2024

Specifications

ISBN-13
9781032264882
Publisher
Routledge
Publication
January 2024
Format
Paperback
Jurisdiction
U.K. ? Countri(es) for reference only

Also available as

Hardback

Details

Tax Avoidance and the Law is a helpful guide to undergraduate and postgraduate students who want a thorough understanding of this dynamic area of Law. The book is written in a way which is easy to follow and conveniently summarises complex case law on tax avoidance.

Tax Avoidance and the Law explores the evolution of the UK’s General Anti-Abuse Rule. It provides a useful comparison with other Western jurisdictions’ anti-avoidance legislation including, the United States of America, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Canada and the EU. The underlying theme of the book rests on the notion that the taxpayer’s subjective motives, intentions or purposes are irrelevant when assessing tax liability.

The book enables students to gain a good grasp of the fundamental issues in tax avoidance in a clear manner.

Table of Contents

Abstract
Introduction 1
Chapter 1: Defining motive, purpose and intention
1.1: Criminal Law perspective
1.2: Psychological perspective
1.3: Philosophical perspective
1.4: Tax Law perspective
1.4 (a) Trading
1.4 (b) Expenditure
1.4 (c) Dividend stripping
1.4 (d) Targeted anti-avoidance rules
1.5: Conclusions
Chapter 2: A move towards motive, intention and purpose
2.1: Tackling tax avoidance
2.2: The divide between supporters of Ramsay and Westminster
2.2 (a) Supporters of Ramsay
2.2 (b) Supporters of Westminster
2.3: Motive, intention and purpose considered across other areas of Tax law
2.3 (a) Trades, professions & vocations
2.3 (b) Expenditure
2.3 (c) Accountancy standards
2.4: Why the "motive approach" is considered
2.5: How motive, intention and purpose are considered
2.5 (a) The "substance over form" doctrine
2.5 (b) Purpose
2.5 (c) Commercial or business purpose
2.5 (d) The step transaction doctrine
2.5 (e) Motive or intention
2.6: Suitability of the motive approach in Tax Law
2.6 (a) Is the motive approach necessary?
2.6 (b) Restructuring transactions
2.6 (c) Inconsistencies
2.6 (d) Constitutional legitimacy of the motive approach
2.7: Conclusion
Chapter 3: The GAAR provisions analysed
3.1: The GAAR: An overview
3.2: The GAAR provisions
3.2 (a) Tax advantage
3.2 (b) Tax arrangement
3.2 (c) The main purpose test
3.2 (d) The double reasonableness test
3.2 (d)(i) "Reasonableness" in Tort and Contract Law
3.2 (d)(ii) "Reasonableness" in Public Law
3.2 (d)(iii) Reasonable man
3.2 (e) Abuse according to the GAAR
3.3: Abuse according to the GAAR guidance
3.4: What is not abusive
3.5: The scope of the GAAR
3.6: The Aaronson Report
3.7: Penalties
3.8: An EU-wide GAAR
3.9: Conclusion
Chapter 4: General anti-avoidance legislation in other jurisdictions
4.1: The United States’ Economic Substance Doctrine ("ESD")
4.1 (a) Common Law background
4.1 (b) The ESD provisions
4.1 (c) Case Law post the American ESD
4.2: The Australian General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.2 (a) Scheme
4.2 (b) Tax benefit
4.2 (c) Purpose
4.3: Australian Case Law post the Australian General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.4: The New Zealand General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.4 (a) Counteraction
4.4 (b) Case Law post the New Zealand General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.5: The South African General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.5 (a) Case Law post the South African General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.6: The Canadian General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.6 (a) Case Law Post the Canadian General Anti-Avoidance Rule
4.7: Conclusion
Chapter 5: Discretion
5.1: The ambiguous GAAR
5.2: HMRC’s role
5.3: Judicial discretion
5.3 (a) Judicial law-making
5.3 (b) Interpretation
5.4: Morality
5.5 Conclusion
Chapter 6: Criticisms of the GAAR
6.1: The main purpose test
6.2: The double reasonableness test
6.3: The scope of the GAAR
6.4: HMRC GAAR Guidance
6.5: The lack of a clearance system
6.6: The UK’s international competitiveness
6.7: Complexity
6.8: Uncertainty
6.9: Constitutional issues
6.10: Conclusion
Chapter 7: Was the GAAR needed?
7.1: Ramsay vs the GAAR
7.1 (a) The overall Ramsay approach
7.1 (b) The main features of the GAAR
7.1 (c) The Ramsay approach verses the GAAR
7.2: Contemporary tax avoidance before the GAAR
7.4: The GAAR as a deterrence
7.5: Conclusion
Chapter 8: Conclusion and recommendations for reform
HKD 592.54 −3%
HKD 610.87

Inclusive of HK delivery

Ready to ship
Delivery Time: around 4-5 weeks
Extra 10 working days if shipping address outside Hong Kong
  • Free HK shipping over HK$1,000
  • International shipping to 35+ countries
Order Form
Save

Recommended

You may also be interested in these books:

More titles from Taxation

View all
Fundamentals of Transfer Pricing, Volume 1: Principles and Practice
Kluwer Law International

Fundamentals of Transfer Pricing, Volume 1: Principles and Practice

Michael Lang; Giammarco Cottani; Raffaele Petruzzi
HKD 1,716.00
Tolley's Worldwide Tax Guide 2025-26
LexisNexis U.K.

Tolley's Worldwide Tax Guide 2025-26

PKF International
HKD 4,109.31
Revenue Recognition Guide (2024)
CCH U.S.

Revenue Recognition Guide (2024)

Scott A. Taub CPA
HKD 6,266.20
Short-Term Rental Platforms as Deemed Suppliers in the EU VAT System
Kluwer Law International

Short-Term Rental Platforms as Deemed Suppliers in the EU VAT System

Emilia Teresa Sroka
HKD 994.98
Taxing the Digital Economy: Theory, Policy and Practice
Cambridge University Press

Taxing the Digital Economy: Theory, Policy and Practice

Craig Elliffe
HKD 353.08
Whillans Tax Data 2026-27 Finance Act edition New
LexisNexis U.K.

Whillans Tax Data 2026-27 Finance Act edition

Kevin Walton; Shilpa Veerappa, Whillans's
HKD 2,054.65