|
Preface to the Second Edition
|
xv
|
|
Foreword to the First Edition by Eric E. Bergsten
|
xvii
|
|
1 Introduction to International Commercial Arbitration
|
1
|
|
A. Purpose
|
1
|
|
B. Defining Characteristics
|
2
|
|
1. Consent
|
2
|
|
2. Nongovernmental Decision Makers
|
2
|
|
3. A Final and Binding Award
|
2
|
|
C. Advantages of Arbitration
|
3
|
|
D. Disadvantages of Arbitration
|
4
|
|
E. The Regulatory Framework
|
5
|
|
F. Institutional Arbitration v. Ad Hoc Arbitration
|
9
|
|
G. Arbitral Institutions
|
10
|
|
1. The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) International Court of Arbitration
|
11
|
|
2. The American Arbitration Association's (AAA) International Center for Dispute Resolution (ICDR)
|
11
|
|
3. The London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA)
|
12
|
|
4. Other Arbitral Institutions
|
12
|
|
H. Arbitrations Involving States
|
13
|
|
1. ICSID Arbitrations
|
13
|
|
2. The Permanent Court of Arbitration
|
13
|
|
I. Other Dispute Resolution Methods
|
14
|
|
1. Mediation
|
14
|
|
2. Conciliation
|
15
|
|
3. Neutral Evaluation
|
15
|
|
4. Expert Determination
|
15
|
|
5. Mini-Trials
|
16
|
|
6. Last-Offer Arbitration (Baseball Arbitration)
|
16
|
|
J. Conclusion
|
16
|
|
2 The Arbitration Agreement
|
18
|
|
A. Function and Purpose
|
18
|
|
1. Arbitration Clauses and Submission Agreements
|
18
|
|
2. Separability
|
19
|
|
B. Validity
|
19
|
|
1. The Writing Requirement
|
21
|
|
a. Recommended Interpretation of Articles II and VII
|
24
|
|
b. Amendment to Article 7 of UNCITRAL Model Law
|
25
|
|
c. U.N. Convention on Use of Electronic Communications
|
28
|
|
d. Other Article 7 Issues
|
29
|
|
e. Effect of the More Favorable Right Provision
|
29
|
|
2. A Defined Legal Relationship
|
31
|
|
3. Capable of Being Settled by Arbitration
|
32
|
|
4. Null and Void, Inoperable, or Incapable of Being Performed
|
33
|
|
a. Null and Void
|
33
|
|
b. Inoperable
|
34
|
|
c. Incapable of Being Performed
|
34
|
|
C. Binding Nonsignatories
|
34
|
|
1. Agency
|
36
|
|
2. Equitable Estoppel
|
36
|
|
3. Implied Consent
|
37
|
|
4. Group of Companies
|
38
|
|
5. Veil Piercing/Alter Ego
|
39
|
|
6. Timing of Objections
|
42
|
|
3 Drafting the Arbitration Agreement
|
43
|
|
A. Essential Requirements
|
45
|
|
1. Choice of Arbitrators
|
46
|
|
2. Seat of the Arbitration
|
47
|
|
3. Language of the Arbitration
|
48
|
|
4. Substantive Law
|
48
|
|
B. Additional Provisions
|
49
|
|
1. International Bar Association Rules on Taking Evidence
|
49
|
|
2. Preliminary Relief
|
50
|
|
3. Technical Expertise
|
51
|
|
4. Multistep Dispute Resolution Clauses
|
51
|
|
5. Dispositive Motions
|
52
|
|
6. Legal Fees and Costs
|
53
|
|
7. Confidentiality
|
54
|
|
8. Expanded Judicial Review
|
55
|
|
9. Waiver of State Immunity
|
56
|
|
10. Multiparty Agreements
|
57
|
|
C. Conclusion
|
58
|
|
4 Applicable Laws and Rules
|
59
|
|
A. Importance of the Law
|
59
|
|
B. Delocalization v. Territoriality
|
60
|
|
1. Arguments Favoring Delocalization
|
60
|
|
2. Arguments Opposing Delocalization
|
61
|
|
3. Some Modern Approaches to Delocalization
|
61
|
|
a. Sports Arbitrations
|
62
|
|
b. Online Arbitrations
|
62
|
|
C. The Lex Mercatoria
|
64
|
|
1. Definition of the Lex Mercatoria
|
64
|
|
2. Application of the Lex Mercatoria
|
66
|
|
a. Contracts between States
|
66
|
|
b. Contracts between a State and a Private Company
|
67
|
|
D. The Parties’ Choice of Law
|
67
|
|
1. The Law Governing the Arbitral Proceedings
|
68
|
|
2. The Rules Governing the Arbitral Proceedings
|
69
|
|
3. The Law Governing the Arbitration Agreement
|
69
|
|
4. The Law Governing Arbitrability
|
72
|
|
5. The Law Governing the Contract
|
73
|
|
a. National or International Law
|
73
|
|
b. Lex Mercatoria
|
74
|
|
c. Unrelated National Law
|
74
|
|
d. Dépeçage
|
76
|
|
e. Renvoi
|
76
|
|
f. Ex Aequo et Bono and Amiable Compositeur
|
77
|
|
E. When Parties Fail to Choose the Seat or the Governing Law
|
78
|
|
1. Failure to Choose a Seat
|
79
|
|
2. Failure to Choose a Governing Law
|
79
|
|
3. Conflicts of Laws
|
80
|
|
4. Voie Indirecte
|
81
|
|
5. Voie Directe
|
81
|
|
F. An Arbitrator's Duty to Apply the Law
|
82
|
|
1. Law or Equity
|
82
|
|
2. Duty to Render an Enforceable Award
|
83
|
|
3. Applying the Law
|
83
|
|
a. The Lex Arbitri
|
83
|
|
b. Mandatory Law
|
84
|
|
c. Mandatory Law and Public Policy
|
84
|
|
5 Judicial Assistance for Arbitration
|
87
|
|
A. Enforcement of Arbitration Agreements
|
88
|
|
1. Extent of Judicial Review
|
88
|
|
2. Competence-Competence
|
91
|
|
B. Anti-Suit Injunctions
|
95
|
|
1. Anti-Suit Injunctions in the United States
|
96
|
|
2. Anti-Suit Injunctions in Europe
|
101
|
|
C. Interim Measures
|
105
|
|
1. Kinds of Interim Measures
|
105
|
|
2. Tribunal or Court – Where to Go for Interim Relief?
|
107
|
|
3. Basis for Interim Measures
|
110
|
|
4. Enforcement of Interim Measures
|
111
|
|
D. Court Assistance in Obtaining Evidence
|
112
|
|
1. Procedural Orders
|
112
|
|
2. National Laws Concerning Court Assistance
|
113
|
|
3. Summons Issued by U.S. Arbitrators
|
114
|
|
4. Tribunal in the United States Seeking Evidence Outside the United States
|
118
|
|
5. Court Assistance in the United States to Foreign Tribunals
|
119
|
|
6. Conclusion
|
120
|
|
6 The Tribunal
|
122
|
|
A. Appointment of Arbitrators
|
122
|
|
1. How Many Arbitrators?
|
122
|
|
2. Qualifications
|
123
|
|
a. Knowledge and Experience
|
123
|
|
b. Lawyers or Nonlawyers
|
123
|
|
c. Professors as Arbitrators
|
124
|
|
d. Language Fluency
|
125
|
|
e. Availability
|
125
|
|
f. Reputation
|
125
|
|
g. Specifications and Requirements
|
126
|
|
3. Method of Selection
|
126
|
|
a. Three Arbitrators
|
126
|
|
i. The Rules
|
126
|
|
ii. The Practice
|
127
|
|
(1) Choosing the Party-Appointed Arbitrators (Coarbitrators)
|
128
|
|
(2) Choosing the Presiding Arbitrator (Chair of the Tribunal)
|
130
|
|
b. A Sole Arbitrator
|
132
|
|
c. Ad Hoc Arbitration
|
133
|
|
4. Interviewing Prospective Arbitrators
|
134
|
|
B. Obligations of Arbitrators
|
135
|
|
1. Independence and Impartiality
|
135
|
|
a. The IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest
|
136
|
|
i. Part I: The General Standards
|
137
|
|
ii. Part II: Practical Application of the General Standards
|
138
|
|
b. The 1987 IBA Rules of Ethics for Arbitrators
|
141
|
|
c. American Arbitration Association–American Bar Association Code of Ethics for Arbitrators in Commercial Disputes
|
142
|
|
d. Duty to Investigate
|
144
|
|
2. Other Obligations
|
145
|
|
C. Challenges to the Arbitrator
|
147
|
|
D. Flawed Conduct of Arbitrators
|
151
|
|
E. Replacement of Arbitrators
|
153
|
|
F. Arbitrator Immunity
|
153
|
|
G. Costs and Fees
|
156
|
|
7 The Arbitral Proceedings
|
157
|
|
A. Beginning the Arbitration
|
158
|
|
B. Preliminary Matters
|
160
|
|
C. Written Submissions
|
166
|
|
D. The Hearing
|
167
|
|
1. Chair Can Decide Procedural Issues
|
167
|
|
2. Scheduling the Hearings
|
168
|
|
3. Seat of the Arbitration
|
168
|
|
4. Language of the Arbitration
|
169
|
|
5. Local Bar Requirements
|
169
|
|
6. Closed Hearings
|
169
|
|
7. Record of Proceedings
|
170
|
|
8. Technology
|
170
|
|
9. Time Limits per Side
|
170
|
|
10. Default of Appearance
|
171
|
|
11. Expedited Proceedings
|
172
|
|
E. Presenting Evidence
|
172
|
|
1. IBA Rules of Evidence
|
173
|
|
2. Burden of Proof
|
174
|
|
3. Documentary Evidence
|
175
|
|
a. Hearsay Evidence
|
176
|
|
b. Authentication
|
176
|
|
c. Document Requests
|
176
|
|
d. Arbitrator Discretion
|
179
|
|
4. Fact Witnesses
|
179
|
|
a. Testimony Prior to the Hearing
|
179
|
|
b. Witness Statements
|
180
|
|
c. Who Can Testify
|
180
|
|
d. Meeting with Witnesses
|
181
|
|
e. Examining Witnesses
|
181
|
|
f. Arbitrator Intervention
|
184
|
|
g. Availability of Witnesses
|
185
|
|
h. Compelling Witness Testimony
|
185
|
|
5. Expert Witnesses
|
185
|
|
F. Closing the Hearing
|
188
|
|
G. Post-Hearing Proceedings
|
188
|
|
8 The Award
|
189
|
|
A. Difference between “Orders” and “Awards”
|
189
|
|
B. Types of Awards
|
190
|
|
1. Final Award
|
190
|
|
2. Partial and Interim Awards
|
191
|
|
3. Consent Award
|
192
|
|
4. Default Award
|
193
|
|
C. Validity of the Award
|
194
|
|
1. Formalities
|
194
|
|
2. Communication
|
194
|
|
3. Time Limits
|
195
|
|
4. Concurring and Dissenting Views
|
195
|
|
5. Scrutiny of the Draft Award
|
195
|
|
6. Finality, Clarity, and Scope
|
196
|
|
D. Remedies and Costs
|
196
|
|
1. Monetary Damages
|
196
|
|
2. Interest
|
196
|
|
3. Other Remedies
|
197
|
|
4. Costs
|
197
|
|
E. Res Judicata Effect of the Award
|
198
|
|
F. Confidentiality of the Award
|
199
|
|
G. Post-Award Proceedings
|
201
|
|
9 Attempts to Set Aside an Award
|
203
|
|
A. Methods of Challenge
|
203
|
|
B. Grounds of Challenge
|
205
|
|
1. Jurisdictional Challenges
|
205
|
|
2. Procedural Challenges
|
206
|
|
3. Challenges Based on the Merits
|
207
|
|
C. Time Limitations
|
209
|
|
D. Effects of a Successful Challenge
|
209
|
|
10 Enforcement of the Award
|
211
|
|
A. Application of International Conventions
|
211
|
|
B. Principles Governing Recognition and Enforcement
|
212
|
|
C. Requirements for Enforcement
|
213
|
|
1. Scope
|
213
|
|
2. Jurisdiction and Forum Non Conveniens
|
214
|
|
3. Procedures for Enforcement
|
216
|
|
D. Grounds for Nonenforcement under the Convention
|
217
|
|
1. Incapacity and Invalidity
|
217
|
|
2. Lack of Notice or Fairness
|
220
|
|
3. Arbitrator Acting in Excess of Authority
|
220
|
|
4. The Tribunal or the Procedure Is Not in Accord with the Parties’ Agreement
|
222
|
|
5. The Award Is Not Yet Binding, or Has Been Set Aside
|
222
|
|
a. A Binding Award
|
222
|
|
b. Effect of a Vacated Award
|
222
|
|
c. The Article V(1)(e) Loophole
|
223
|
|
d. The Court's Discretion to Ignore the Article V(1)(e) Loophole
|
224
|
|
e. Deference to Local Law under Article VII
|
224
|
|
f. Enforcement of Vacated Awards
|
224
|
|
6. The Last Two Defenses under Article V
|
226
|
|
a. Subject Matter Not Arbitrable
|
226
|
|
b. Public Policy
|
228
|
|
E. Conclusion
|
229
|
|
11 Investment Arbitration
|
230
|
|
A. Growth of Foreign Investment and Investment Arbitration
|
230
|
|
B. Investor Protection
|
231
|
|
1. The Washington (ICSID) Convention
|
231
|
|
a. Background
|
231
|
|
b. ICSID Jurisdictional Requirements
|
232
|
|
i. Consent
|
232
|
|
ii. Contracting State or National of Another Contracting State
|
233
|
|
iii. Legal Disputes and Investments
|
235
|
|
c. Special Features of ICSID Arbitrations
|
236
|
|
i. Delocalization
|
236
|
|
ii. Recognition, Enforcement, and Execution
|
236
|
|
iii. Publication of Awards
|
238
|
|
d. Additional Facility Rules
|
238
|
|
2. Bilateral Investment Treaties
|
239
|
|
a. Background
|
239
|
|
b. Substantive Rights
|
240
|
|
c. Enforcing Rights under a BIT
|
241
|
|
3. Multilateral Investment Treaties
|
242
|
|
4. Investor Protection Legislation
|
243
|
|
C. Overlap of Treaty-Based Rights and Contract-Based Rights
|
243
|
|
1. The Source of the Right
|
243
|
|
2. Umbrella Clauses
|
245
|
|
3. Distinguishing Contract and Treaty Claims
|
247
|
|
4. Coordinating Contracts with Treaties
|
250
|
|
Appendices
|
|
|
A. The United Nations Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (The New York Convention) (1958)
|
253
|
|
B. UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (original 1985 version)
|
259
|
|
C. Revised Articles of the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (2006)
|
273
|
|
D. UNCITRAL Recommendation Regarding the Interpretation of Article II, Paragraph 2, and Article VII, Paragraph 1, of the New York Convention
|
279
|
|
E. IBA Rules on the Taking of Evidence in International Arbitration
|
282
|
|
F. IBA Rules of Ethics for International Arbitrators 1987
|
309
|
|
G. IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in International Arbitration
|
314
|
|
H. The AAA–ABA Code of Ethics for Arbitrators in Commercial Disputes
|
332
|
|
I. Model Clauses
|
346
|
|
J. Useful Arbitration Websites
|
349
|
|
Index
|
357
|