Conveyancing / Tenancy / Land

Time Limited Interests in Land

Edited by Professor Cornelius Van Der Merwe · Professor Alain-Laurent Verbeke
Cambridge University Press June 2012

Specifications

ISBN-13
9781107026124
Publisher
Cambridge University Press
Publication
June 2012
Format
Hardback , 576 pages
Jurisdiction
International ? Countri(es) for reference only

Details

A comprehensive comparative treatment of six instances of time-limited interests in land as encountered in fourteen European jurisdictions. The survey explores the commercial or social origins of each legal institution concerned and highlights their enforceability against third parties, their content and their role in land development. The commercial purpose of residential and agricultural leases is contrasted with the social aim of personal servitudes (and its common-law equivalent liferent) to provide sustenance for life to mostly family members making the latter an important estate planning device. Whereas the ingrained principles of leases and personal servitudes restrain the full exploitation of land, it is indicated that public authorities and private capital could combine to turn the old-fashioned time-limited institutions of hereditary building lease (superficies) and hereditary land lease (emphyteusis) into pivotal devices in alleviating the acute shortage of social housing and in promoting the fullest exploitation of pristine agricultural land.

• First extensive European research on the content and characteristic features of time-limited interests in land

• Highlights divergence in social policy to help readers understand how social justifications underlying different legal institutions can influence the principles ingrained in these institutions

• Underscores the important role the institutions of personal servitudes and lease can play in estate planning

Table of Contents

General editors’ preface
xiii
Preface
xv
Notes on the contributors
xviii
List of abbreviations
xx
Part I        Introduction and context1
1
1             Setting the scene
3
2             General introduction
12
3             Historical evolution of the maxim ‘sale breaks hire’
19
4             The many faces of usufruct
33
Part II       Case studies
57
Case 1        Various instances of time-limited interests
59
Comparative observations
59
Austria
66
Belgium
72
Denmark
77
England
79
France
85
Germany
90
Greece
94
Hungary
97
Italy
103
Netherlands
104
Poland
106
Portugal
112
Scotland
117
South Africa
124
Spain
127
Case 2        What happens if land subject to a time-limited interest is conveyed to a third party?
132
Comparative observations
132
Austria
135
Belgium
137
Denmark
138
England
138
France
139
Germany
141
Greece
141
Hungary
143
Italy
144
Netherlands
145
Poland
146
Portugal
148
Scotland
149
South Africa
152
Spain
154
Case 3        What happens if land subject to a time-limited interest is attached in execution of a debt or the landowner becomes insolvent? Does a previously registered mortgage rank above a subsequently constituted time-limited interest?
157
Comparative observations
157
Austria
162
Belgium
164
Denmark
165
England
166
France
166
Germany
168
Greece
169
Hungary
171
Italy
173
Netherlands
174
Poland
176
Portugal
178
Scotland
181
South Africa
183
Spain
185
Case 4        What happens if the holder of a time-limited interest is dispossessed?
189
Comparative observations
189
Austria
192
Belgium
195
Denmark
196
England
197
France
198
Germany
201
Greece
202
Hungary
203
Italy
204
Netherlands
205
Poland
206
Portugal
207
Scotland
209
South Africa
210
Spain
212
Case 5        Duty of the holder of a time-limited interest to repair, replace and renew
214
Comparative observations
214
Austria
223
Belgium
227
Denmark
230
England
231
France
235
Germany
238
Greece
241
Hungary
245
Italy
247
Netherlands
250
Poland
251
Portugal
253
Scotland
257
South Africa
262
Spain
267
Case 6        Entitlements of the holder of a time-limited interest to fruits of agricultural property
270
Comparative observations
270
Austria
277
Belgium
279
Denmark
282
England
283
France
284
Germany
287
Greece
289
Hungary
294
Italy
296
Netherlands
298
Poland
301
Portugal
303
Scotland
306
South Africa
310
Spain
312
Case 7        To what extent may the holder of a time-limited interest convert his/her interest in the land?
316
Comparative observations
316
Austria
320
Belgium
321
Denmark
323
England
323
France
325
Germany
326
Greece
327
Hungary
328
Italy
330
Netherlands
331
Poland
332
Portugal
333
Scotland
334
South Africa
336
Spain
337
Case 8        Remedies of the landowner against misconduct by the holder of a time-limited interest
340
Comparative observations
340
Austria
344
Belgium
345
Denmark
347
England
348
France
349
Germany
350
Greece
351
Hungary
352
Italy
352
Netherlands
353
Poland
354
Portugal
355
Scotland
357
South Africa
359
Spain
360
Case 9        To what extent can a time-limited interest be sold or donated, burdened with a mortgage or a separate limited right, attached in execution proceedings and included in the holder’s insolvency assets?
363
Comparative observations
363
Austria
370
Belgium
375
Denmark
378
England
379
France
380
Germany
382
Greece
385
Hungary
387
Italy
389
Netherlands
391
Poland
392
Portugal
394
Scotland
396
South Africa
401
Spain
405
Case 10       Use of time-limited interests in land for land development
409
Comparative observations
409
Austria
413
Belgium
415
Denmark
415
England
416
France
416
Germany
419
Greece
420
Hungary
421
Italy
422
Netherlands
425
Poland
425
Portugal
425
Scotland
426
South Africa
429
Spain
430
Case 11       The effect of an option to purchase and an obligation to maintain in land development
431
Comparative observations
431
Austria
434
Belgium
435
Denmark
437
England
437
France
438
Germany
439
Greece
441
Hungary
441
Italy
442
Netherlands
442
Poland
442
Portugal
443
Scotland
444
South Africa
446
Spain
447
Case 12       Development of an existing building and land development by a public institution
448
Comparative observations
448
Austria
450
Belgium
450
Denmark
452
England
452
France
452
Germany
453
Greece
453
Hungary
454
Italy
454
Netherlands
456
Poland
456
Portugal
456
Scotland
457
South Africa
458
Spain
458
Part III      Concluding remarks
461
Case 1
463
Case 2
471
Case 3
472
Case 4
473
Case 5
475
Case 6
478
Case 7
481
Case 8
483
Case 9
486
Case 10
490
Case 11
491
Case 12
493
Modern significance of time-limited interests in land
495
Appendix: the importance of the various time-limited interests in land in individual jurisdictions
498
Bibliography
507
General index
524
Country index
537

About the Author

Professor Cornelius Van Der Merwe
University of Stellenbosch, South Africa

Professor Alain-Laurent Verbeke
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium

Out of stock
This title is currently unavailable for purchase.
  • Free HK shipping over HK$1,000
  • International shipping to 35+ countries

Recommended

You may also be interested in these books:

More titles from Conveyancing / Tenancy / Land

View all