Evidence, Respect and Truth: Knowledge and Justice in Legal Trials

Evidence › Courts and Procedure

Evidence, Respect and Truth: Knowledge and Justice in Legal Trials

By Liat Levanon
Hart Publishing April 2024

Specifications

ISBN-13
9781509942695
Publisher
Hart Publishing
Publication
April 2024
Format
Paperback
Jurisdiction
U.K. ? Countri(es) for reference only

Also available as

Hardback

Details

Should statistical evidence be used as legal evidence?

This book takes a holistic approach to addressing this question by considering the relationship between evidence, randomness and justifying reasons. It situates the problem of 'evidence and chance' within the broader sweep of the administration of criminal justice.

The book draws a distinction between evidence that can justify critical judgments and evidence that can only justify non-critical judgments. It considers the way that evidence can justify critical judgment only if it can support all the propositions of the judgment, thus leaving none of the propositions random and explains that evidence can justify non-critical judgments even where it leaves some propositions random. One implication is that 'naked statistical evidence' can only justify non-critical judgments. The evidential distinction is explored and attuned in a range of legal and related extra-legal contexts including:

  • criminal and civil judgments;
  • allocation of burdens based on profiling (like in 'stop and search');
  • distribution of resources based on profiling
  • private judgements in everyday life
  • justified belief

Table of Contents

Introduction
PART I: THE EPISTEMOLOGY OF LEGAL FACT FINDING
1. The Rationality of Belief and Error Eliminability
I. Epistemology and Proof Paradoxes: A Very Brief Introduction
II. Legal Practice: Logically Ineliminable Errors
III. Rational Legal Belief
IV. Error Eliminability and Truth Tracking
V. Error Eliminability and Eliminative Induction
2. The Challenge from Error and Error Eliminability
I. Sceptical Challenges
II. Error Eliminability and the Argument about Error
III. Error Eliminability and Other Sceptical Arguments
3. Between the Epistemic and the Practical: Pushing against a Persisting Difficulty
I. Does Knowledge Have Practical Value?
II. The Practical Value of Epistemic Reasons: Stability of Belief and Successful Action
III. Pragmatism: The Epistemic Value of Practical Reasons
IV. A Shared Method of Reasoning for the Epistemic and the Practical
V. An Overarching Value: Introducing Respect
PART II: THE PRACTICALITY OF LEGAL FACT FINDING
4. Respecting, Asserting and Error Eliminability
I. Legal Assertions
II. Informing of Wrongdoing
III. Reasons to Inform as Reasons to Assert: Respect for Persons
IV. Respect and the Norm of (Legal) Assertion
V. Conclusions
5. Respecting, Doing Justice and Error Eliminability
I. Justice as Fairness and Justified Belief: The Convergence of Justifications
II. The Context of a Legal Trial
III. Accounting for the Convergence and Taking it Forward: Respect, Evidential Conditions and 'Disaster Prevention'
IV. A More Rigid Account: Epistemic Value as a Source of Moral Value
V. Conclusions
6. Resolution
I. Conflict Resolution Outside and Inside Legal Discourse
II. Error Eliminability and Legal Resolution
III. Some Procedural Implications
7. From Respect to Cost Analysis in Criminal Judgments
I. Evidence of Past Misconduct
II. Statistical Evidence that Indicates Propensity
III. Statistical Evidence that Does Not Indicate Propensity
IV. A Mutual Tragedy: The Error of the Legal System
V. Practical Implications: Aesthetics, Ethics and the Value of Choice
VI. Error Eliminability and Cost Analysis
PART III: RESPONSIBILITY
8. Epistemic and Moral Responsibility
I. Legal Assertions and Epistemic Responsibility
II. Legal Assertions and Practical Responsibility
III. Conclusions
PART IV: BEYOND LEGAL FACT FINDING
9. Applications
I. Artificial Intelligence
II. Algorithmic Sentencing: Predicting how a Human Would Make Retributive Judgements
III. Algorithmic Prediction of Students' Grades
IV. Allocation of Resources in the Private and Public Domains
V. Automated Cars and Other Dangerous Machines
VI. Profiling and Individual Risk Prediction Based on Group Affiliation
VII. Personal Attitudes
VIII. Beliefs about Groups and the Problem of Prejudice
HKD 554.71 −3%
HKD 571.87

Inclusive of HK delivery

Ready to ship
Delivery Time: around 4-5 weeks
Extra 10 working days if shipping address outside Hong Kong
  • Free HK shipping over HK$1,000
  • International shipping to 35+ countries
Order Form
Save

Recommended

You may also be interested in these books:

More titles from Courts and Procedure

View all
Transforming Summary Justice: Modernisation in the Lower Criminal Courts
Routledge

Transforming Summary Justice: Modernisation in the Lower Criminal Courts

Jenni Ward
HKD 2,168.79
Practical Handbook on the Operation of the Evidence Convention 4th Edition
HccH

Practical Handbook on the Operation of the Evidence Convention 4th Edition

Christophe Bernasconi
Archbold: Criminal Pleading, Evidence and Practice 2026
Sweet & Maxwell U.K.

Archbold: Criminal Pleading, Evidence and Practice 2026

His Honour Judge Mark Lucraft KC
HKD 4,807.32
Abuse of Process in the Civil Courts Pre-order
Oxford University Press

Abuse of Process in the Civil Courts

Charles Gibson; Paul Skinner; Rachel Tandy
HKD 1,891.50
The In-House Lawyer: Print Subscription
Legalease Subscriptions

The In-House Lawyer: Print Subscription

The Practical Guide to Public Inquiries
Hart Publishing

The Practical Guide to Public Inquiries

Isabelle Mitchell; Peter Watkin Jones; Sarah Jones; Emma Ireton
HKD 1,261.00